refactor(filetype)!: allow vim.filetype.match to use different strategies (#18895)

This enables vim.filetype.match to match based on a buffer (most
accurate) or simply a filename or file contents, which are less accurate
but may still be useful for some scenarios.

When matching based on a buffer, the buffer's name and contents are both
used to do full filetype matching. When using a filename, if the file
exists the file is loaded into a buffer and full filetype detection is
performed. If the file does not exist then filetype matching is only
performed against the filename itself. Content-based matching does the
equivalent of scripts.vim, and matches solely based on file contents
without any information from the name of the file itself (e.g. for
shebangs).

BREAKING CHANGE: use `vim.filetype.match({buf = bufnr})` instead 
of `vim.filetype.match(name, bufnr)`

runtime/doc/lua.txt

@@ -2064,14 +2064,45 @@ add({filetypes})                                          *vim.filetype.add()*
                     {filetypes}  (table) A table containing new filetype maps
                                  (see example).
 
-match({name}, {bufnr})                                  *vim.filetype.match()*
-                Find the filetype for the given filename and buffer.
+match({arg})                                            *vim.filetype.match()*
+                Perform filetype detection.
+
+                The filetype can be detected using one of three methods:
+                1. Using an existing buffer
+                2. Using only a file name
+                3. Using only file contents
+
+                Of these, option 1 provides the most accurate result as it
+                uses both the buffer's filename and (optionally) the buffer
+                contents. Options 2 and 3 can be used without an existing
+                buffer, but may not always provide a match in cases where the
+                filename (or contents) cannot unambiguously determine the
+                filetype.
+
+                Each of the three options is specified using a key to the
+                single argument of this function. Example:
+>
+
+    -- Using a buffer number
+    vim.filetype.match({ buf = 42 })
+
+    -- Using a filename
+    vim.filetype.match({ filename = "main.lua" })
+
+    -- Using file contents
+    vim.filetype.match({ contents = {"#!/usr/bin/env bash"} })
+<
 
                 Parameters: ~
-                    {name}   (string) File name (can be an absolute or
-                             relative path)
-                    {bufnr}  (number|nil) The buffer to set the filetype for.
-                             Defaults to the current buffer.
+                    {arg}  (table) Table specifying which matching strategy to
+                           use. It is an error to provide more than one
+                           strategy. Accepted keys are:
+                           • buf (number): Buffer number to use for matching
+                           • filename (string): Filename to use for matching.
+                             Note that the file need not actually exist in the
+                             filesystem, only the name itself is used.
+                           • contents (table): An array of lines representing
+                             file contents to use for matching.
 
                 Return: ~
                     (string|nil) If a match was found, the matched filetype.

runtime/filetype.lua

@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ vim.api.nvim_create_augroup('filetypedetect', { clear = false })
 vim.api.nvim_create_autocmd({ 'BufRead', 'BufNewFile' }, {
   group = 'filetypedetect',
   callback = function(args)
-    local ft, on_detect = vim.filetype.match(args.file, args.buf)
+    local ft, on_detect = vim.filetype.match({ buf = args.buf })
     if ft then
       vim.api.nvim_buf_set_option(args.buf, 'filetype', ft)
       if on_detect then

runtime/lua/vim/filetype.lua

@@ -2047,7 +2047,7 @@ local pattern = {
     end
   end, { priority = -math.huge + 1 }),
   ['XF86Config.*'] = starsetf(function(path, bufnr)
-    return require('vim.filetype.detect').xfree86(bufnr)
+    return require('vim.filetype.detect').xfree86()
   end),
   ['%.zcompdump.*'] = starsetf('zsh'),
   -- .zlog* and zlog*
@@ -2185,17 +2185,24 @@ end
 local function dispatch(ft, path, bufnr, ...)
   local on_detect
   if type(ft) == 'function' then
+    if bufnr then
       ft, on_detect = ft(path, bufnr, ...)
+    else
+      -- If bufnr is nil (meaning we are matching only against the filename), set it to an invalid
+      -- value (-1) and catch any errors from the filetype detection function. If the function tries
+      -- to use the buffer then it will fail, but this enables functions which do not need a buffer
+      -- to still work.
+      local ok
+      ok, ft, on_detect = pcall(ft, path, -1, ...)
+      if not ok then
+        return
+      end
+    end
   end
 
   if type(ft) == 'string' then
     return ft, on_detect
   end
-
-  -- Any non-falsey value (that is, anything other than 'nil' or 'false') will
-  -- end filetype matching. This is useful for e.g. the dist#ft functions that
-  -- return 0, but set the buffer's filetype themselves
-  return ft
 end
 
 ---@private
@@ -2214,29 +2221,74 @@ local function match_pattern(name, path, tail, pat)
   return matches
 end
 
---- Find the filetype for the given filename and buffer.
+--- Perform filetype detection.
 ---
----@param name string File name (can be an absolute or relative path)
----@param bufnr number|nil The buffer to set the filetype for. Defaults to the current buffer.
+--- The filetype can be detected using one of three methods:
+---  1. Using an existing buffer
+---  2. Using only a file name
+---  3. Using only file contents
+---
+--- Of these, option 1 provides the most accurate result as it uses both the buffer's filename and
+--- (optionally) the buffer contents. Options 2 and 3 can be used without an existing buffer, but
+--- may not always provide a match in cases where the filename (or contents) cannot unambiguously
+--- determine the filetype.
+---
+--- Each of the three options is specified using a key to the single argument of this function.
+--- Example:
+---
+--- <pre>
+---   -- Using a buffer number
+---   vim.filetype.match({ buf = 42 })
+---
+---   -- Using a filename
+---   vim.filetype.match({ filename = "main.lua" })
+---
+---   -- Using file contents
+---   vim.filetype.match({ contents = {"#!/usr/bin/env bash"} })
+--- </pre>
+---
+---@param arg table Table specifying which matching strategy to use. It is an error to provide more
+---                 than one strategy. Accepted keys are:
+---                   * buf (number): Buffer number to use for matching
+---                   * filename (string): Filename to use for matching. Note that the file need not
+---                                        actually exist in the filesystem, only the name itself is
+---                                        used.
+---                   * contents (table): An array of lines representing file contents to use for
+---                                       matching.
 ---@return string|nil If a match was found, the matched filetype.
 ---@return function|nil A function that modifies buffer state when called (for example, to set some
 ---                     filetype specific buffer variables). The function accepts a buffer number as
 ---                     its only argument.
-function M.match(name, bufnr)
+function M.match(arg)
   vim.validate({
-    name = { name, 's' },
-    bufnr = { bufnr, 'n', true },
+    arg = { arg, 't' },
   })
 
-  -- When fired from the main filetypedetect autocommand the {bufnr} argument is omitted, so we use
-  -- the current buffer. The {bufnr} argument is provided to allow extensibility in case callers
-  -- wish to perform filetype detection on buffers other than the current one.
-  bufnr = bufnr or api.nvim_get_current_buf()
+  if not (arg.buf or arg.filename or arg.contents) then
+    error('One of "buf", "filename", or "contents" must be given')
+  end
 
+  if (arg.buf and arg.filename) or (arg.buf and arg.contents) or (arg.filename and arg.contents) then
+    error('Only one of "buf", "filename", or "contents" must be given')
+  end
+
+  local bufnr = arg.buf
+  local name = bufnr and api.nvim_buf_get_name(bufnr) or arg.filename
+  local contents = arg.contents
+
+  if name then
     name = normalize_path(name)
+  end
 
   local ft, on_detect
 
+  if not (bufnr or name) then
+    -- Sanity check: this should not happen
+    assert(contents, 'contents should be non-nil when bufnr and filename are nil')
+    -- TODO: "scripts.lua" content matching
+    return
+  end
+
   -- First check for the simple case where the full path exists as a key
   local path = vim.fn.resolve(vim.fn.fnamemodify(name, ':p'))
   ft, on_detect = dispatch(filename[path], path, bufnr)

test/functional/lua/filetype_spec.lua

@@ -3,6 +3,7 @@ local exec_lua = helpers.exec_lua
 local eq = helpers.eq
 local clear = helpers.clear
 local pathroot = helpers.pathroot
+local command = helpers.command
 
 local root = pathroot()
 
@@ -23,7 +24,7 @@ describe('vim.filetype', function()
           rs = 'radicalscript',
         },
       })
-      return vim.filetype.match('main.rs')
+      return vim.filetype.match({ filename = 'main.rs' })
     ]])
   end)
 
@@ -37,7 +38,7 @@ describe('vim.filetype', function()
           ['main.rs'] = 'somethingelse',
         },
       })
-      return vim.filetype.match('main.rs')
+      return vim.filetype.match({ filename = 'main.rs' })
     ]])
   end)
 
@@ -48,7 +49,7 @@ describe('vim.filetype', function()
           ['s_O_m_e_F_i_l_e'] = 'nim',
         },
       })
-      return vim.filetype.match('s_O_m_e_F_i_l_e')
+      return vim.filetype.match({ filename = 's_O_m_e_F_i_l_e' })
     ]])
 
     eq('dosini', exec_lua([[
@@ -59,7 +60,7 @@ describe('vim.filetype', function()
           [root .. '/.config/fun/config'] = 'dosini',
         },
       })
-      return vim.filetype.match(root .. '/.config/fun/config')
+      return vim.filetype.match({ filename = root .. '/.config/fun/config' })
     ]], root))
   end)
 
@@ -72,11 +73,13 @@ describe('vim.filetype', function()
           ['~/blog/.*%.txt'] = 'markdown',
         }
       })
-      return vim.filetype.match('~/blog/why_neovim_is_awesome.txt')
+      return vim.filetype.match({ filename = '~/blog/why_neovim_is_awesome.txt' })
     ]], root))
   end)
 
   it('works with functions', function()
+    command('new')
+    command('file relevant_to_me')
     eq('foss', exec_lua [[
       vim.filetype.add({
         pattern = {
@@ -87,7 +90,7 @@ describe('vim.filetype', function()
           end,
         }
       })
-      return vim.filetype.match('relevant_to_me')
+      return vim.filetype.match({ buf = 0 })
     ]])
   end)
 end)