Most SDL functions used to indicate success or failure using an int return code. These functions have been changed to return SDL_bool.
Here is a coccinelle patch to change code that previously compared the return value to 0 and changes it to a boolean test:
@ bool_return_type @
identifier func =~ "^(SDL_AddEventWatch|SDL_AddHintCallback|SDL_AddSurfaceAlternateImage|SDL_AddVulkanRenderSemaphores|SDL_BindAudioStream|SDL_BindAudioStreams|SDL_BlitSurface|SDL_BlitSurface9Grid|SDL_BlitSurfaceScaled|SDL_BlitSurfaceTiled|SDL_BlitSurfaceTiledWithScale|SDL_BlitSurfaceUnchecked|SDL_BlitSurfaceUncheckedScaled|SDL_CaptureMouse|SDL_ClearAudioStream|SDL_ClearClipboardData|SDL_ClearComposition|SDL_ClearError|SDL_ClearProperty|SDL_ClearSurface|SDL_CloseIO|SDL_CloseStorage|SDL_ConvertAudioSamples|SDL_ConvertEventToRenderCoordinates|SDL_ConvertPixels|SDL_ConvertPixelsAndColorspace|SDL_CopyFile|SDL_CopyProperties|SDL_CopyStorageFile|SDL_CreateDirectory|SDL_CreateStorageDirectory|SDL_CreateWindowAndRenderer|SDL_DateTimeToTime|SDL_DestroyWindowSurface|SDL_DetachVirtualJoystick|SDL_DisableScreenSaver|SDL_EnableScreenSaver|SDL_EnumerateDirectory|SDL_EnumerateProperties|SDL_EnumerateStorageDirectory|SDL_FillSurfaceRect|SDL_FillSurfaceRects|SDL_FlashWindow|SDL_FlipSurface|SDL_FlushAudioStream|SDL_FlushRenderer|SDL_GL_DestroyContext|SDL_GL_GetAttribute|SDL_GL_GetSwapInterval|SDL_GL_LoadLibrary|SDL_GL_MakeCurrent|SDL_GL_SetAttribute|SDL_GL_SetSwapInterval|SDL_GL_SwapWindow|SDL_GetAudioDeviceFormat|SDL_GetAudioStreamFormat|SDL_GetCameraFormat|SDL_GetClosestFullscreenDisplayMode|SDL_GetCurrentRenderOutputSize|SDL_GetCurrentTime|SDL_GetDXGIOutputInfo|SDL_GetDateTimeLocalePreferences|SDL_GetDisplayBounds|SDL_GetDisplayUsableBounds|SDL_GetGDKDefaultUser|SDL_GetGDKTaskQueue|SDL_GetGamepadSensorData|SDL_GetGamepadTouchpadFinger|SDL_GetHapticEffectStatus|SDL_GetJoystickBall|SDL_GetMasksForPixelFormat|SDL_GetPathInfo|SDL_GetRectUnion|SDL_GetRectUnionFloat|SDL_GetRenderClipRect|SDL_GetRenderColorScale|SDL_GetRenderDrawBlendMode|SDL_GetRenderDrawColor|SDL_GetRenderDrawColorFloat|SDL_GetRenderLogicalPresentation|SDL_GetRenderLogicalPresentationRect|SDL_GetRenderOutputSize|SDL_GetRenderSafeArea|SDL_GetRenderScale|SDL_GetRenderVSync|SDL_GetRenderViewport|SDL_GetSensorData|SDL_GetStorageFileSize|SDL_GetStoragePathInfo|SDL_GetSurfaceAlphaMod|SDL_GetSurfaceBlendMode|SDL_GetSurfaceClipRect|SDL_GetSurfaceColorKey|SDL_GetSurfaceColorMod|SDL_GetTextInputArea|SDL_GetTextureAlphaMod|SDL_GetTextureAlphaModFloat|SDL_GetTextureBlendMode|SDL_GetTextureColorMod|SDL_GetTextureColorModFloat|SDL_GetTextureScaleMode|SDL_GetTextureSize|SDL_GetWindowAspectRatio|SDL_GetWindowBordersSize|SDL_GetWindowMaximumSize|SDL_GetWindowMinimumSize|SDL_GetWindowPosition|SDL_GetWindowRelativeMouseMode|SDL_GetWindowSafeArea|SDL_GetWindowSize|SDL_GetWindowSizeInPixels|SDL_GetWindowSurfaceVSync|SDL_HideCursor|SDL_HideWindow|SDL_Init|SDL_InitHapticRumble|SDL_InitSubSystem|SDL_LoadWAV|SDL_LoadWAV_IO|SDL_LockAudioStream|SDL_LockProperties|SDL_LockSurface|SDL_LockTexture|SDL_LockTextureToSurface|SDL_MaximizeWindow|SDL_MinimizeWindow|SDL_MixAudio|SDL_OpenURL|SDL_OutOfMemory|SDL_PauseAudioDevice|SDL_PauseAudioStreamDevice|SDL_PauseHaptic|SDL_PlayHapticRumble|SDL_PremultiplyAlpha|SDL_PremultiplySurfaceAlpha|SDL_PushEvent|SDL_PutAudioStreamData|SDL_RaiseWindow|SDL_ReadStorageFile|SDL_ReadSurfacePixel|SDL_ReadSurfacePixelFloat|SDL_RegisterApp|SDL_ReloadGamepadMappings|SDL_RemovePath|SDL_RemoveStoragePath|SDL_RemoveTimer|SDL_RenamePath|SDL_RenameStoragePath|SDL_RenderClear|SDL_RenderCoordinatesFromWindow|SDL_RenderCoordinatesToWindow|SDL_RenderFillRect|SDL_RenderFillRects|SDL_RenderGeometry|SDL_RenderGeometryRaw|SDL_RenderLine|SDL_RenderLines|SDL_RenderPoint|SDL_RenderPoints|SDL_RenderPresent|SDL_RenderRect|SDL_RenderRects|SDL_RenderTexture|SDL_RenderTexture9Grid|SDL_RenderTextureRotated|SDL_RenderTextureTiled|SDL_RequestAndroidPermission|SDL_RestoreWindow|SDL_ResumeAudioDevice|SDL_ResumeAudioStreamDevice|SDL_ResumeHaptic|SDL_RumbleGamepad|SDL_RumbleGamepadTriggers|SDL_RumbleJoystick|SDL_RumbleJoystickTriggers|SDL_RunHapticEffect|SDL_SaveBMP|SDL_SaveBMP_IO|SDL_SendAndroidMessage|SDL_SendGamepadEffect|SDL_SendJoystickEffect|SDL_SendJoystickVirtualSensorData|SDL_SetAppMetadata|SDL_SetAppMetadataProperty|SDL_SetAudioDeviceGain|SDL_SetAudioPostmixCallback|SDL_SetAudioStreamFormat|SDL_SetAudioStreamFrequencyRatio|SDL_SetAudioStreamGain|SDL_SetAudioStreamGetCallback|SDL_SetAudioStreamInputChannelMap|SDL_SetAudioStreamOutputChannelMap|SDL_SetAudioStreamPutCallback|SDL_SetBooleanProperty|SDL_SetClipboardData|SDL_SetClipboardText|SDL_SetCursor|SDL_SetFloatProperty|SDL_SetGamepadLED|SDL_SetGamepadMapping|SDL_SetGamepadPlayerIndex|SDL_SetGamepadSensorEnabled|SDL_SetHapticAutocenter|SDL_SetHapticGain|SDL_SetJoystickLED|SDL_SetJoystickPlayerIndex|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualAxis|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualBall|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualButton|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualHat|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualTouchpad|SDL_SetLinuxThreadPriority|SDL_SetLinuxThreadPriorityAndPolicy|SDL_SetLogPriorityPrefix|SDL_SetMemoryFunctions|SDL_SetNumberProperty|SDL_SetPaletteColors|SDL_SetPointerProperty|SDL_SetPointerPropertyWithCleanup|SDL_SetPrimarySelectionText|SDL_SetRenderClipRect|SDL_SetRenderColorScale|SDL_SetRenderDrawBlendMode|SDL_SetRenderDrawColor|SDL_SetRenderDrawColorFloat|SDL_SetRenderLogicalPresentation|SDL_SetRenderScale|SDL_SetRenderTarget|SDL_SetRenderVSync|SDL_SetRenderViewport|SDL_SetScancodeName|SDL_SetStringProperty|SDL_SetSurfaceAlphaMod|SDL_SetSurfaceBlendMode|SDL_SetSurfaceColorKey|SDL_SetSurfaceColorMod|SDL_SetSurfaceColorspace|SDL_SetSurfacePalette|SDL_SetSurfaceRLE|SDL_SetTLS|SDL_SetTextInputArea|SDL_SetTextureAlphaMod|SDL_SetTextureAlphaModFloat|SDL_SetTextureBlendMode|SDL_SetTextureColorMod|SDL_SetTextureColorModFloat|SDL_SetTextureScaleMode|SDL_SetThreadPriority|SDL_SetWindowAlwaysOnTop|SDL_SetWindowAspectRatio|SDL_SetWindowBordered|SDL_SetWindowFocusable|SDL_SetWindowFullscreen|SDL_SetWindowFullscreenMode|SDL_SetWindowHitTest|SDL_SetWindowIcon|SDL_SetWindowKeyboardGrab|SDL_SetWindowMaximumSize|SDL_SetWindowMinimumSize|SDL_SetWindowModalFor|SDL_SetWindowMouseGrab|SDL_SetWindowMouseRect|SDL_SetWindowOpacity|SDL_SetWindowPosition|SDL_SetWindowRelativeMouseMode|SDL_SetWindowResizable|SDL_SetWindowShape|SDL_SetWindowSize|SDL_SetWindowSurfaceVSync|SDL_SetWindowTitle|SDL_SetiOSAnimationCallback|SDL_ShowAndroidToast|SDL_ShowCursor|SDL_ShowMessageBox|SDL_ShowSimpleMessageBox|SDL_ShowWindow|SDL_ShowWindowSystemMenu|SDL_StartTextInput|SDL_StartTextInputWithProperties|SDL_StopHapticEffect|SDL_StopHapticEffects|SDL_StopHapticRumble|SDL_StopTextInput|SDL_SyncWindow|SDL_TimeToDateTime|SDL_TryLockMutex|SDL_TryLockRWLockForReading|SDL_TryLockRWLockForWriting|SDL_TryWaitSemaphore|SDL_UnlockAudioStream|SDL_UpdateHapticEffect|SDL_UpdateNVTexture|SDL_UpdateTexture|SDL_UpdateWindowSurface|SDL_UpdateWindowSurfaceRects|SDL_UpdateYUVTexture|SDL_Vulkan_CreateSurface|SDL_Vulkan_LoadLibrary|SDL_WaitConditionTimeout|SDL_WaitSemaphoreTimeout|SDL_WarpMouseGlobal|SDL_WriteStorageFile|SDL_WriteSurfacePixel|SDL_WriteSurfacePixelFloat)$";
@@
(
func(
...
)
- == 0
|
- func(
+ !func(
...
)
- < 0
|
- func(
+ !func(
...
)
- != 0
|
- func(
+ !func(
...
)
- == -1
)
It was intended to make the API easier to use, but various automatic garbage collection all had flaws, and making the application periodically clean up temporary memory added cognitive load to using the API, and in many cases was it was difficult to restructure threaded code to handle this.
So, we're largely going back to the original system, where the API returns allocated results and you free them.
In addition, to solve the problems we originally wanted temporary memory for:
* Short strings with a finite count, like device names, get stored in a per-thread string pool.
* Events continue to use temporary memory internally, which is cleaned up on the next event processing cycle.
Noticed this in SDL-1.2 where gcc-13 emits a -Wuse-after-free warning.
No such warning in SDL2 and SDL3, because unlike SDL1.2, SDL_realloc()
is not a macro expanding to libc realloc(). It warns, of course, if
SDL_realloc() is replaced with plain realloc():
src/stdlib/SDL_iconv.c: In function 'SDL_iconv_string_REAL':
src/stdlib/SDL_iconv.c:824:39: warning: pointer 'oldstring' may be used after 'realloc' [-Wuse-after-free]
824 | outbuf = string + (outbuf - oldstring);
| ~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~~~~~
src/stdlib/SDL_iconv.c:818:30: note: call to 'realloc' here
818 | string = (char *)realloc(string, stringsize + sizeof(Uint32));
| ^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Otherwise, they might find out strings with malformed UTF-8 sequences produce
a different amount of codepoints than the count returned here, overflowing
buffers that might be allocated based on the results.
SDL_strcasecmp (even when calling into a C runtime) does not work with
Unicode chars, and depending on the user's locale, might not work with
even basic ASCII strings.
This implements the function from scratch, using "case-folding,"
which is a more robust method that deals with various languages. It
involves a hashtable of a few hundred codepoints that are "uppercase" and
how to map them to lowercase equivalents (possibly increasing the size of
the string in the process). The vast majority of human languages (and
Unicode) do not have letters with different cases, but still, this static
table takes about 10 kilobytes on a 64-bit machine.
Even this will fail in one known case: the Turkish 'i' folds differently
if you're writing in Turkish vs other languages. Generally this is seen as
unfortunate collateral damage in cases where you can't specify the language
in use.
In addition to case-folding the codepoints, the new functions also know how
to decode the various formats to turn them into codepoints in the first
place, instead of blindly stepping by one byte (or one wchar_t) per
character.
Also included is casefolding.txt from the Unicode Consortium and a perl
script to generate the hashtable from that text file, so we can trivially
update this if new languages are added in the future.
A simple test using the new function:
```c
#include <SDL3/SDL.h>
int main(void)
{
const char *a = "α ε η";
const char *b = "Α Ε Η";
SDL_Log(" strcasecmp(\"%s\", \"%s\") == %d\n", a, b, strcasecmp(a, b));
SDL_Log("SDL_strcasecmp(\"%s\", \"%s\") == %d\n", a, b, SDL_strcasecmp(a, b));
return 0;
}
```
Produces:
```
INFO: strcasecmp("α ε η", "Α Ε Η") == 32
INFO: SDL_strcasecmp("α ε η", "Α Ε Η") == 0
```
glibc strcasecmp() fails to compare a Greek lowercase string to its uppercase
equivalent, even with a UTF-8 locale, but SDL_strcasecmp() works.
Other SDL_stdinc.h functions are changed to be more consistent, which is to
say they now ignore any C runtime and often dictate that only English-based
low-ASCII works with them.
Fixes Issue #9313.
- Always use internal qsort and bsearch implementation.
- add "_r" reentrant versions.
The reasons for always using the internal versions is that the C runtime
versions' callbacks are not mark STDCALL, so we would have add bridge
functions for them anyhow, The C runtime qsort_r/qsort_s have different
orders of arguments on different platforms, and most importantly: qsort()
isn't a stable sort, and isn't guaranteed to give the same ordering for
two objects marked as equal by the callback...as such, Visual Studio and
glibc can give different sort results for the same data set...in this
sense, having one piece of code shared on all platforms makes sense here,
for reliabillity.
bsearch does not have a standard _r version at all, and suffers from the
same SDLCALL concern. Since the code is simple and we would have to work
around the C runtime, it's easier to just go with the built-in function
and remove all the CMake C runtime tests.
Fixes#9159.
__builtin_memcpy, as well as __builtin_memset and __builtin_memmove, needn't be
inlined but emitted as a libc call, leading to infinitely recursive calls.
Fixes https://github.com/libsdl-org/SDL/issues/9090
Modern C runtimes have well optimized memset and memcpy, so use those instead of dispatching into SDL's versions. In addition, some compilers can analyze memset and memcpy calls and directly turn them into optimized assembly.
warning C28251: Inconsistent annotation for 'SDL_vsscanf_REAL': this instance has no annotations. See c:\projects\sdl-experimental\include\sdl3\sdl_stdinc.h(597).
warning C28252: Inconsistent annotation for 'SDL_vsnprintf_REAL': _Param_(3) has 'SAL_IsFormatString("printf")' on the prior instance. See c:\projects\sdl-experimental\include\sdl3\sdl_stdinc.h(600).
warning C28253: Inconsistent annotation for 'SDL_vswprintf_REAL': _Param_(3) has 'SAL_IsFormatString("printf")' on this instance. See c:\projects\sdl-experimental\include\sdl3\sdl_stdinc.h(601).
warning C28251: Inconsistent annotation for 'SDL_vasprintf_REAL': this instance has no annotations. See c:\projects\sdl-experimental\include\sdl3\sdl_stdinc.h(603).
